Blog Layout

How Strong Is Welding, And Which Type Is The Strongest?

Nov 30, 2022
Which type of welding is strongest

One of the most efficient methods for joining metal in fabrication is welding. In general, all welding processes can result in incredibly strong bonds. But is one type of welding superior to the other?


Various factors can determine the strongest weld in addition to the welding process. A number of variables are involved, including: 

  • the type of metals used
  • the size and length of the weld
  • the filler that was used
  • the operator's or welder's expertise


So, let's take a closer look at the different types of welding and which is the strongest technique. 


The Two Types Of Welding: MIG (Metal Inert Gas) vs TIG (Tungsten Inert Gas)

Two Types Of Welding

Welds come in a variety of types. MIG, TIG, Stick Welding, and Arc Welding are the most common ones. However, in this article, we will be focusing on MIG and TIG.


MIG (Metal Inert Gas)

MIG or Metal Inert Gas

MIG, which stands for Metal Inert Gas, is also referred to as Gas Metal Arc Welding (GMAW). To do traditional MIG welding, you need the following:

  • welding gun
  • power source
  • wire feed unit
  • consumable welding electrode
  • source of shielding gas


MIG welding parts are far more readily available and less expensive than TIG welding supplies. During MIG welding, the electrode wire forms an arc with the base metal being welded, melts, and fuses the two components. During this welding process, a gas bubble of protection is also created. This shields the weld from contaminants from the outside.


This type of weld is not recommended for 

  • Outdoors
  • Locations with moving air
  • Damp areas


Due to the difficulty of "fusing" with MIG welding, it has been dubbed the "hot glue gun" of welding. Contrary to TIG, which actually fuses the two materials, the MIG electrode wire serves as an adhesive between the two materials. This means that you can join different types of metals using MIG welding. It is more frequently applied to: 

  • Aluminium
  • Steel
  • Stainless steel
  • Heavy-duty structural plates
  • 26-gauge sheet metal


But, it is too weak for cast iron and too strong for thin aluminium. The ability to accelerate production and shorten lead times is a major advantage of MIG welding. 


MIG is also quite straightforward to learn and master in a few weeks. However, MIG welding occasionally results in weak and less ductile welds, which are common quality issues. To solve these issues, avoid materials that are too thick or too thin, along with impure or unclean materials.


TIG (Tungsten Inert Gas)

TIG or Tungsten Inert Gas

TIG, which stands for Tungsten Inert Gas, is also called Gas Tungsten Arc Welding (GTAW). Although TIG welding is difficult to master because of how hot it gets, welders have come up with some ingenious solutions over time. Some techniques include:

  • Using minimum power
  • Angle the torch appropriately
  • Using the right type of tungsten


TIG welding is also done manually. For TIG welding, you will need:

  • Welding torch
  • Constant-current welding power supply
  • An electrode of your choice
  • Gas for shielding
  • Grinder
  • Filler metals


Additionally, you'll have to decide between hand control or pedal control, though most TIG welders use both hands. Since its electrode is non-consumable and constructed of tungsten, unlike MIG, you will eventually need to buy tungsten for maintenance after a few uses. 


With the exception of zinc and zinc alloys, TIG welding is typically utilised for nonferrous materials like:

  • Aluminium
  • Magnesium
  • Nickel
  • Titanium
  • Copper


To weld different metals with TIG, a compatible filler metal is required. The result of TIG welding is a durable and high-quality fusion. Since the tungsten rod is thinner than a stick rod, TIG welds are delicate and precise. It can therefore result in some appealing joins.


The drawback of TIG is that it can be time-consuming and slow. Moreover, despite the fact that its electrode is non-consumable, the TIG machine is initially expensive. It should only be managed and operated by trained employees. 


MIG vs TIG

The materials you're working with will determine your best welding option. When done correctly, TIG welding may produce the best quality weld on any metal, but it fails to attach to thicker materials. Whereas MIG welding may be used on metals of any thickness, but it produces welds of lower quality and is mainly effective on steel and aluminium.


Despite having advantages and disadvantages of their own, TIG and MIG welding can both be the best option for your upcoming welding project. MIG welding is quicker and easier to do than TIG welding, but TIG welding provides you with better accuracy and a more attractive weld.


Which Welding Is The Strongest?

Metal works in Malaysia

Due to the intense heat it generates and the delayed cooling rate that follows, TIG welding is frequently regarded as the strongest weld. Nevertheless, MIG is also a great option for the strongest type of weld because it may produce a strong joint.


The answer to this topic is fairly complex because the material to which a weld is applied determines its strength. There are three factors to consider when assessing a weld's strength which are:

  • Length
  • Size 
  • Filler


As a result, there is no simple answer to the question, "What is the strongest sort of weld?" The strength of the weld relies on the material and the welder's expertise.


Looking for metal welding services in Malaysia? Visit Choong Ngai Engineering now! 

Prior to selecting a welding technique, it is crucial to consider the complexity and quantity of the parts that will be welded. Time and cost plays an important role as well so be sure to keep that in mind. 


If you're looking for a reliable quality welding services provider in Malaysia, look no further than Choong Ngai Engineering Works. We are a leading provider of quality welding services Malaysia and provide the best possible service to our clients. Contact us now!

Industries That Benefit From Metal Stamping
18 Jan, 2024
Explore the various industries that benefit from the metal stamping technique and find out how metal bending services in Malaysia aid and progress these fields.
Round Metal Fabrication Malaysia
15 Jan, 2024
Discover the differences between liquid and powder coating with this informative article. Find out which method is best for you based on the needs of your project.
12 Jan, 2024
Welding, the modern industrial world's "alchemy," joins metals and other substances with the skill of a surgeon and the durability of a titan. However, flaws can occur in this complex combination of heat and metal. Welding flaws are sneaky rivals that can weaken structures and jeopardise integrity. In this piece, we'll take a tour of the welding world and look for the most common mistakes. We'll examine every imperfection, from porosity to cracks, identifying their causes and exploring methods to stop them from recurring. So, whether you're an expert welder or a newbie enthusiast, come along with us as we strive to perfect our craft and make every weld a shining example of our expertise. Overlap Overlap happens when the weld's face goes past its toe. As the filler material spreads over the entire weld joint and cools, fusing to the foundation material is difficult. Proper welding is the best way to avoid the overlap welding defect. The operator may avoid overlap by keeping the welding rod held at the proper angle and moving at a moderate pace. Welding too slowly can also result in an overlap. Craters Craters are a frequent welding flaw that develops during aluminium welding. They form at the weld bead's tip. Ignoring craters will create stress points, which will ultimately cause the weld to crack. Craters can be avoided by properly terminating the weld bead. They occur when the welding is halted before a pass is completed. Additionally, craters can be avoided by filling the space between the tack welds and the weld bead. Even in the unlikely event that craters form, they can usually be repaired, provided the weld bead is intact. Simply fill in the crater by creating an arc from a point immediately beyond the hole and going back over it. Porosity
11 Jan, 2024
Metal stamping is an advanced and widely utilised manufacturing process that has come a long way since its beginnings in coin-making during the 7th century. It’s used to create components for various industries such as automotive, electronics, etc., while also being able to save time and money through efficiency while ensuring precision parts of high quality are delivered. In this blog post, we’ll cover all aspects of metal stamping, including its many methods and machines involved in the process, and discuss its advantages when employed. What Is Metal Stamping? Metal stamping is a process that has been around since the seventh century when it was originally used to make coins. Today, metal stamping dies are employed to create shapes and patterns on sheet metal with high accuracy and efficiency for various industries. The advantages of this manufacturing method include: Low cost Versatility Rapid production cycles Precision results in its formation Unfortunately, certain types of metals cannot be effectively shaped using this technique, which should be taken into account by users considering such an approach. Die-stamping techniques include progressive die stamping (for mass-producing parts) and transfer punching, where punches remove material from one area at once while transferring them simultaneously onto another piece. Four-slide equipment or multi-slide presses allow complex geometries and intricate designs, among other applications. At the same time, fine blanking can deliver precise cutting dimensions due to specialised tool designs especially suited for softer materials like aluminium alloys. These technologies bring unique benefits depending on requirements and/or industry needs, making them ideal choices based on those parameters. The Various Types Of Metal Stamping Process
Sheet Metals In Architecture
08 Nov, 2023
Discover architecture's elegant union of art and engineering with sheet metal fabrication. Find out the benefits that are altering the way modern buildings are built.
Metal Fabrication Safety Measures
02 Nov, 2023
Discover the most crucial safety measures for metal fabrication in Malaysia. Learn how these precautions are vital for protecting artists in this dynamic industry.
Exploring 6 Techniques To Cut Sheet Metal
31 Oct, 2023
Discover the fundamentals of sheet metal fabrication. Find out how these cutting techniques can help you become a better sheet metal fabricator.
Ball Screw And How Are They Used
27 Oct, 2023
Learn about the importance of ball screws in heavy machinery spare parts in Malaysia. Discover how these vital parts improve machinery precision and efficiency.
Sheet Metal Fabrication Used In The Automobile Industry
04 Oct, 2023
Metal fabrication in Malaysia is vital for the creation of automobiles. Read to find out more about how metal fabrication contributes to the automobile industry.
Metal Spinning And What Are Their Advantages
02 Oct, 2023
Metal spinning is the shaping of metal while using pressure to mould it into the desired shape. Discover the benefits of metal bending services in Malaysia.
More Posts
Share by: